Showing posts with label Asia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Asia. Show all posts

Thursday, June 16, 2022

Staying in Touch in Korea

Following up here, I agonized a little over what to do for phone communication while visiting South Korea recently.  My current plan didn't (AFAICT) offer an international pay-as-you-go plan, which would have been perfect.  So then I thought I'd rent a SIM in Korea (very easy to do) then had nightmares imagining I'd lose either the new or current one.  So, it's also easy to rent an entire phone, and very cheap to do so.

In the end, I did nothing more than download Kakaotalk.  And I hardly used it.

I managed to get by just fine using email and Facebook messenger.  And believe me, I hate Facebook!  But my Korean friends use it, and it worked out fine.

When it comes to travel I always find that less is more.  Another stop at the airport to rent a SIM or phone is just that -- another 15 minutes I'm not enjoying myself.

So at least for me, everything worked out fine with the caveat that it's very easy to find free wifi in Korea, or to buy a data card at a convenience store and roll with that.  Then again, I got along just fine with coffee shops.

Also, be prepared to use an app to get a taxi at night in Seoul, and probably smaller cities as well.  There's a shortage of cabbies right now.  If you ask nicely, I'm sure any good restaurant or hotel will order one for you but be prepared to ask.  They will go right past you if you try flagging them yourself, because they already have a fare booked in advance.

Sunday, July 18, 2021

"misrepresented to further a political agenda"

Vox on how the wellness and new-age health industry is kinda sort very racist, and Orientalist in particular:

"Cultural exports are a complex, inevitable result of globalization, and cultural appropriation doesn’t always carry negative effects. As Asian-inspired practices and treatments edge toward the mainstream, the problem isn’t necessarily appropriation. It’s what appropriation can produce: an Orientalist perspective toward non-Western practices that can be misrepresented to further a political agenda.

The process by which this happens is likely familiar to anyone with a passing knowledge of Gwyneth Paltrow’s Goop, although this type of appropriation predates the brand by decades. It usually begins with an influential (usually white) Westerner who encounters a practice with origins in East or South Asia. The person integrates the tradition into their lifestyle, publicly touts its benefits, and helps disseminate a version of the practice to their own community. (Such was the case for acupuncture in 1971, after a New York Times reporter wrote about the benefits of his treatment in China.)"

As always, there's nothing wrong with "borrowing" from other cultures but it takes a hell of lot of work to fully understand the context and history and what you're borrowing.

Of course, read the whole article which is very good and gets into the overlap between right-wing Nazis and ostensibly "left" New Age hippie, anti-vaccine types.

Thursday, April 29, 2021

"a battleground for bigger powers"

"Wang's analogy of us as human fertilizer revived thoughts I had been thinking for a long time.  True enough, as Chinese, we genuinely felt that our lives were misused here, but as I have observed earlier, no matter how abysmal our situation was there were always others who had it worse.  By now I understood why occasionally some Korean civilians were hostile to us.  To them we had come here only to protect China's interests -- by so doing, we couldn't help but ruin their homes, fields, and livelihoods.  From their standpoint, if the Chinse army hadn't crossed the Yalu, millions of lives, both civilian and military, would have been saved.  Of course, the United States would then have occupied all of Korea, forcing China to build defenses in Manchuria, which would have been much more costly than sending troops to fight in our neighboring country.  As it was, the Koreans had taken the brunt of the destruction of this war, whereas we Chinese were here mainly to keep its flames away from our border.  Or, as most of the POW's believed, perhaps rightly, we had served as cannon fodder for the Russians.  It was true that the Koreans had started the war themselves, but a small country like theirs could only end up being a battleground for bigger powers.  Whoever won this war, Korean would be a loser."

-- Ha Jin, War Trash

Saturday, March 6, 2021

"So many of us have experienced it, sometimes for the first time in our lives"

America is seeing a rise in anti-Asian racism and violence.  Of course, it's nothing new:
"Among these attacks, there are notable patterns: Women were more likely than men to say they were targeted, several assaults involved children, and harassment was more likely to occur at retail stores and pharmacies since people have been limiting their activities during the pandemic.

'So many of us have experienced it, sometimes for the first time in our lives,' says Manjusha Kulkarni, the executive director of the Asian Pacific Policy and Planning Council, a group that helped set up this tracker. 'It makes it much harder to go to the grocery store, to take a walk, to be outside our homes.'

This rise in anti-Asian harassment has occurred as the US continues to grapple with Covid-19, and it follows months of xenophobic rhetoric by former President Donald Trump, who frequently used racist names for the virus and associated it with Asian Americans.

The broader uptick in racism, however, isn’t just fueled by the pandemic. Although the uncertainty of the outbreak — coupled with the former president’s rhetoric — has amplified it, this prejudice is rooted in longstanding biases toward Asian Americans that have persisted since some of the earliest immigrants came to the US generations ago."

Among the many pathologies of Trump supporters, the one that's always jumped out at me is how quick they are to blame other people for their own anxieties and personal deficiencies as human beings.

Wednesday, December 9, 2020

"faith in Americans crumbled"

In a "Letter From Korea," Catherine Kim asks if Koreans still look up to America, the "beautiful country."  The answer is mixed, but with a healthy portion of "no, not really":
"Korea’s admiration of the U.S. was always bound to drop somewhat as Korea grew from one of the poorest countries in the world into its 10th-largest economy, says Lee Hyun-song, a professor of interpretation and translation at the Hankuk University of Foreign Studies who wrote a 2015 article about Koreans' changing perception of Americans up to the early 2000s. But, he says, Trump’s tenure, and really 2020 in particular, has accelerated that process, especially among younger generations of Koreans, who are expressing more pride for their country and less likely to turn to the U.S. for guidance.

'There was a strong belief that there was a lot to learn from the U.S., but then that faith in Americans crumbled after they voted for Trump,' he says. 'As we’ve watched the U.S. fail to contain Covid-19 and rebel against mask-wearing through the media, we’ve come to realize that the U.S. is no longer a more "developed" country than us.'”

Koreans aren't stupid.  They will, at decisive moments, be forced to choose between the growing might of China and the apparent decline of the U.S.  There is no middle ground available, when China can punish South Korea overnight merely by barring its citizens from visiting Jeju Island.

And they're correct to realize it isn't just Trump, who is a symptom of the cancer in the American body, not a cause.  It's the millions of people -- anti-science, anti-alliance, anti-common sense -- who voted for him.  (Let's be honest -- anti-reality, frankly.)

It's his supporters who are the deep, intractable problem.  They're also loud and clear in their spite -- "America first" means, by definition, long-term allies and alliances get to go "last."

Tuesday, November 24, 2020

"we will act as a meteorite and hit the outdated ways of the older generations"

It's hard to see beyond COVID, but with Cheeto Hitler finally on his way out and clearing up some of the air for things of actual importance, it's a good time to remind ourselves that Thailand has a really shitty military dictatorship and the people are fighting to dismantle it:
"'We will act as a meteorite and hit the outdated ways of the older generations in this country,' the protest organisers explained. 'We will talk about all the topics that the dinosaurs don’t want to hear.' Inflatable dinosaurs wobbled in the afternoon heat, representing the Thai government. The symbols are playful, but the message is clear: teenagers want change.

A student-led protest movement has shaken Thailand over the past five months. Young people have taken to the streets to call for a true democracy, and have risked jail to shatter a taboo that has long prevented frank, public discussion of the monarchy. Their protests, attended by tens of thousands, present one of the boldest challenges that the Thai royal family has faced in living memory.

Demonstrators say they are not calling for the monarchy to be abolished, but for it to be reformed, accountable to the people and not above the law. They have also called for the prime minister, Prayuth Chan-ocha, a former army general who came to power in a 2014 coup, to stand down, and for changes to the constitution to make the political system more democratic."

Let's not pretend that a new Biden administration magically washes away the past four years of dictatorship-humping done by Mike Pompeo.  But at the very least it's a turn towards a time when we at least paid lip-service to the idea of promoting democracy.

Wednesday, June 17, 2020

The Politics of Meat

As the coronavirus rages around the world and the debate over Asian "wet markets" (where animals are slaughtered on demand) continues, I was surprised to find out so many of them currently operate in America:
"Some so-called 'wet markets' in Asia, named for the common practice of hosing them down with water, stock exotic wildlife alongside live animals, providing a potential nexus for diseases to spread. This has led to growing calls around the world to ban them, even though the precise history of the coronavirus pandemic, widely thought to have originated at a seafood market in Wuhan, is still unclear.
But the term 'wet markets' has become confusing in the process, mixing up wildlife consumption with less exotic traditions, such as the poultry markets of New York. This has led to a situation where, in the rush to create a safer food system, culturally significant food practices, which pose comparatively minor public health risks, are coming under threat.
In New York, animal rights groups have begun campaigning vigorously on issues of food safety, including staging protests outside markets. A recent petition by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (Peta) urges officials to shut down 'blood-soaked slaughterhouses' in New York, specifically referring to the facilities as 'wet markets' in an accompanying video. Peta has also urged the World Health Organization (WHO) to denounce live animal markets globally. The WHO has resisted these demands, saying that live markets provide food and jobs for millions of people.
There are a ton of things intersecting  here: animal rights, public health, and access to fresh food in poor neighborhoods.  And who's not to say a freshly killed chicken from one of these dingy markets isn't significantly healthier than the pre-packaged, steroid-laden chicken breasts from a "clean" meat packing facility?

Tuesday, April 21, 2020

Well, This (Might Have) Happened

Apparently Kim Jong-un had a botched heart surgery and is now in a coma.

2020, your script-writer deserves a raise as always.

Sunday, April 12, 2020

"forcing governments to take their wellbeing seriously"

I have a lot to say -- entirely positive -- about living in South Korea during the ongoing coronavirus epidemic.  Sure, it was scary at first, and my sleep schedule is probably shot for the rest of 2020 at best.  But living here and seeing what an effective government response looks like, and what a fully-functional, first-world health care system should be, has been an eye-opener.  This piece by Tae Hoon Kim in The Guardian gets to the point:
"The restoration of democracy in 1987 did not change this state-led economic model and infrastructure management. What changed, however, was the attitude of the people. The toppling of the military dictatorship in 1987 was the result of a series of nationwide protests. Throughout the 1990s and 2000s, South Korea saw numerous mass civil protests against a wide range of issues, from the import of US beef to government mismanagement of a ferry accident in 2014. The apex of this mass mobilisation were the demonstrations against the previous resident, Park Geun-hye. The protests continued from October 2016 to March 2017. On 3 December 2016, an estimated 2.3 million people took to the streets, almost 4% of the entire population. These subsequently led to Park’s impeachment and imprisonment.
Korean politics since the 1990s can thus be characterised as a period during which citizens became increasingly emboldened in their relationship with the state, forcing governments to take their wellbeing seriously. One area that this has been the most conspicuous is in public transportation, energy and healthcare. For the average person, these are everyday services that all citizens have the right to enjoy, and which are paid for by taxpayers’ money. To put it in more utilitarian terms, they are the most tangible barometers with which to judge the government’s commitment to its citizens. Failure to improve their qualities and manage them properly almost always leads to a loss of votes for the ruling party in upcoming elections."
Korean history is nothing if not complex.  But no doubt a country that has high expectations for its leaders, and is willing to hold them to account when they fuck up, is the defining characteristic of a healthy, functioning democracy.

The thing is, South Korea is hardly a den of Bernie supporters (or the rough Asian-Socialist equivalent).  I have friends (usually older, but still) who will routinely bitch about "Reds" in both the government and the dreaded, hated labor unions.  (A lot of his comes from right-wing indoctrination during two years of compulsory military service.)

But still, even the most right-wing Korean politician would get booed / laughed off the stage if they suggested privatizing the health care system or subways and buses.

Which is to say, the only thing preventing America from finally joining the rest of the industrialized world and putting a national health system in place is a lack of imagination.  An imagination of what's possible (as demonstrated by literally every other rich country in the world) and an imagination of who the government should serve -- the citizens, not the markets.

Monday, April 6, 2020

Predictable And Depressing

Brittany Wong on the double-damage of the coronavirus upon Asians and Asian-Americans in particular:
"Encounters like those experienced by Cruz’s parents have become commonplace for Asian Americans in the wake of the current global public health emergency.
Because COVID-19 originated in Wuhan, China, Asian Americans have been widely scapegoated, regardless of whether they’re Chinese or not. (Asian Americans ― Indonesians, Chinese, Koreans, Thai, Filipinos, and others ― aren’t a monolith, but for Americans with bigoted views, that hardly matters.)
Asian Americans of every descent are dealing not only with the virus itself, but verbal and physical violence from xenophobic neighbors. The choice to wear a mask or not is widely debated among friends and relatives ― do you wear one to protect yourself from the virus or does it draw unnecessary attention?"
This virus is killing so many, disrupting lives and families, and simultaneously traumatizing the fuck out of all of us.

When did "don't be a fucking asshole is a crisis situation" become such an impossibly high bar for so many white Americans?

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

"the waiter dropped forks in front of them, and chopsticks by me"

Vanessa Hua is the daughter of Chinese immigrant parents.  She didn't learn to use chopsticks -- resisted using them! -- into her 30's:
"In the suburbs east of San Francisco, we were one of a handful of Chinese families, and my classmates teased me and snubbed me from early on. I tried to fit in, getting a perm and donning Guess jeans, Esprit canvas tote bags, and other signifiers of suburban girlhood in the late 1980s — and I’d no sooner use chopsticks than bind my feet. At home, and at Chinese restaurants, I insisted on a fork, in a muddled form of protest, of patriotism, to claim that I was truly American. My parents must have tried to teach me how to use chopsticks, in the murkiness before my memories begin, but eventually, they had to let it go. They had demanding careers in science and engineering, and it must have taken everything in them to get our family through the day, let alone try to stem the tide of assimilation.
In college, I started taking a tentative interest in my heritage, but knew no better than my non-Chinese friends where to go for a late night bite in San Francisco’s Chinatown. We ended up at a dive with paper napkins and Formica tables, the air heavy with grease. Without a word, the waiter dropped forks in front of them, and chopsticks by me. My friends protested. I felt pleased, but then almost immediately like a fraud — hyphenated, never quite American or Chinese enough. Most likely, the waiter had decided he didn’t want the hassle of coming back to deliver forks. Maybe, more often than not, tourists didn’t know how to use chopsticks. And I didn’t either — at least, not correctly, not then and not years later, despite my father’s renewed efforts to teach me."
What a beautiful piece of writing.  Absolutely read the whole thing.

I'm reminded of a passage in Roy Choi's great autobiography about his life as a first-generation Korean-American, L.A. Son, and how his father would hit him if he ever caught him speaking Korean.  (The idea being that excising Korean would hasten his learning of English.)

Thursday, May 16, 2019

"beer soup was common"

One copacetic thing about being a long-term expat in South Korea, or Asia, is that since I'm not into Big Western Breakfasts I never really encounter them unless I'm staying in a hotel.  What I'm trying to say is, American Breakfast is elitist bullshit:
"American breakfast begins in Europe, which provided the food norms imported by early colonizers. There, the day’s first meal had emerged from centuries of prohibition under the Catholic Church. 'There was a period of time in England and western Europe where eating breakfast was sort of tied to gluttony,' says Heather Arndt Anderson, the author of Breakfast: A History. That all changed with the Protestant Reformation, when morning sustenance became more broadly permissible, if not all that exciting, or even distinct from everything else people ate. Lack of refrigeration meant the meal was usually sour and tepid. In Germany, beer soup was common.
In early America, breakfast remained a matter of convenience for most people: bread; preserved meats; repurposed leftovers; and things, like eggs, that were easy to prepare and regularly available to rural families, Arndt Anderson says.
According to Krishnendu Ray, a professor of food studies at New York University, that’s consistent with how much of the world still approaches the day’s first meal. 'Poorer people everywhere, especially in places like India and China, eat the same kind of food for meal after meal,' he says. 'The strict differentiation of meals is partly an American thing, but partly a thing of upward mobility.' Breakfast food, as a concept, is a luxury. As colonial America developed into a more robust culture with distinct class markers, breakfast started to change with it."
I do miss blueberry or chocolate chip pancakes on very rare occasions.  I'm not a monster.

Thursday, April 18, 2019

Who Gets To Be "Lucky"?

What's in a name?  For a few newly opened Chinese restaurants run by non-Chinese chefs, a fair amount of drama, if not outright problematic thinking:
"However, by the mid-20th century, changing conditions in both countries saw a shift. When Mao Zedong and his People’s Republic of China party took power in 1949, the country was declared an atheist state; as part of the Cultural Revolution he led, social values were upended, ancient religions were banned, and traditional Chinese pictographic characters were simplified to fewer strokes. Meanwhile, in the U.S., Jung writes that 'as non-Chinese customers became better acquainted with Chinese names and more tolerant toward Chinese culture, it became fashionable after 1950 to return to Chinese names.'
That leaves the 'lucky' name with a smack of old-timeyness, but there are still plenty of them — American-Chinese restaurants often don’t change names when a new owner takes over, for consistency’s sake. In other cases, restaurant owners might lean in on the 'lucky' name to intentionally create a sense of nostalgia; many of the new restaurants from non-Chinese owners employ it alongside a cheeky, retro feel to their decor and branding. Think old-fashioned poster art or cigarette labels with women in Mandarin dresses, old Chinese newspapers, or Tiki bar aesthetics. Nostalgia is a big ticket in U.S. restaurants today: It’s the secret sauce in everything from dishes to decor to cocktails at such esteemed restaurants as the Grill and Rocco Dispirito’s new Standard Grill, both in New York."
I've always like Andrew Zimmern on T.V., so I was bummed that he was such a dick-head regarding his new (and apparently not very good) Asian restaurant.

Tuesday, April 2, 2019

An Aussie In Pyongyang

The title says it all -- "I'm the only Australian living in North Korea. Let me tell you about it" :
"The Pyongyang Metro is always full of 'phone zombies' staring intently at games, movies or the news. Pretty much the only person I’ve met who doesn’t have a smartphone is my 73-year-old literary theory teacher, who has stuck with her 2000s Nokia-style device.
But perhaps the most insightful experiences I’ve had have been talking with various locals.
A taxi driver, for example, told me he knew Australia was a popular tourist destination. He knew we had backed the 'US imperialists' in the Korean war, which his grandfather had fought in, but said he hoped I would be the first of many foreigners to live in his home town.
In the dormitory, I shared a room for four months with a local student majoring in English. In most ways, he wasn’t too different from a typical bloke in his early 20s. An avid football fan, he loved Neymar and Messi, whom he followed alongside the April 25 Sports Club, a local Pyongyang team. He enjoyed the odd drink (and a more regular cigarette)."
Of course, a smart US foreign policy would be working to understand these internal changes and adjust accordingly.

Of course, there is no such thing as a smart US foreign policy these days.

Thursday, February 28, 2019

Hanoi


Of course Trump wants to spin his Hanoi debacle as a "walking away" situation, a tie, a neutral outcome.

However, Kim Jong-un will train back to Pyongyang more powerful, and more assured of his power, than ever.  No doubt he wasn't exactly in a bad position pre-Singapore, but now he and North Korea have been legitimized as an international power, not a dictatorial backwater undeserving of meeting with the United States president.

North Korea is stronger than ever before.  The US has gotten nothing.  Japan is rightfully bemused at how dumb a large portion of the American electorate must be.  Russia is laughing at us, because of course they are.

And South Korea?  Well, Moon Jae-in was probably hoping for another "success" like Singapore but at the very least he has no reason not to continue working on his own directly with Kim on detente between South and North.

That's a silver lining of sorts, albeit a slim one.

Sunday, January 27, 2019

It's Racism, Stupid Part Two

An American who was adopted from South Korea 40 years ago (Korean "foreign adoption boom"), who is married and has kids in the U.S., has been deported back to South Korea because Trump:
"Crapser’s case also highlights the shaky legal status of possibly thousands of South Korean adoptees in the United States whose parents may have failed to get them citizenship, potentially leaving them vulnerable to deportation if they acquire a criminal record in a country that’s becoming increasingly aggressive about going after undocumented immigrants.
Crapser, who was named Shin Seong-hyeok by his Korean mother, is one of five adoptees who the Seoul government confirms now live in South Korea after being deported from the United States. Several of the deportees have reportedly dealt with mental health issues and served jail time in South Korea for assault and other crimes.
Activists say the South Korean government has done a poor job tracking deported adoptees and that the real number is almost certainly larger. Officials wouldn’t provide details about the other deportees."
This is cruelty and white supremacism, pure and simple.  Crapser has brought the first lawsuit against a Korean adoption agency and while very much an uphill battle, here's hoping he wins.  It's beyond belief that international adoption agencies can operate without any mechanism to ensure the adoptees have full citizenship in their target countries.

Friday, July 13, 2018

Dogmatisms

There's a lot of good food writing out there, but Taste has really emerged as my favorite site for such a thing.  Here's a really informative piece on eating dog meat, and the fraught issues of cultural relativism and outright racism that have always been involved:
"Throughout Asia, the practice of eating dog has been a locus point regarding generational differences, class mobility, and the seriousness of Western scrutiny. During the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea, earlier this year, various news outlets and social media posts put a spotlight on the practice. Alex Paik, managing director of AP Communications, a company that promotes Korean culture, was firm in his response to my queries: 'The vast majority of Koreans are grossed out at the thought of eating dog,' he said. Since the Korean War, he told me, the perception of Koreans as enthusiastic dog eaters has haunted them. The truth is, those who embrace the practice have always been a minority: Most Koreans, he wrote, are firmly in the 'dogs are pets' camp. 'Usually we hear about some older folk who believe in it having special, revitalizing properties.'”
Yes and no.  I have adult students who eat dog, albeit not all that often.  They're quick to tell me that dog-meat dogs are not pets.  That is, you can eat dog and own a pet dog with no logical contradiction -- the one you're eating isn't really a pet, but no different than a chicken, pig, or cow before slaughter.

And for what it's worth, I tried it once when I lived in Seoul.  It tasted like a particularly stringy yet greasy cut of beef.  Also, it's not cheap.

Friday, May 11, 2018

Kim Jong-un Is Going To Drink Trump's Milkshake

There's a lot to say about what's going on between Cheeto Hitler and Kim Jong-un right now, with a face-to-face meeting set for next month, but I'll simply throw out this thought: trading three hostages for a summit that basically legitimizes Kim's rule and North Korea as a global force to be reckoned with was not a Nobel Prize-level act of statesmanship.

It was the definition of a sucker bet.

Wednesday, April 4, 2018

Never Start A Trade War In Asia

It's clear that no amount of pussy-grabbing, vulgarity, racism, or spite will ever alienate Trump from his supporters.  (In fact, those are the reasons they like him.)

But a self-inflicted, outright trade war with China?

The reason I think this holds some water beyond all the White Racial Resentment stuff is two fold.  First, Americans have grown used to a Walmart lifestyle dependent on cheap shit from China and the rest of Asia.  Given a few weeks, that could be over.

Second, China is (obviously) a lot smarter than Trump.  They're going after agricultural goods from Red States like soybeans and hogs.

Again, this doesn't mean Trump is finished by a long shot.  But it means he has to explain the benefits of a trade war that not even his advisers wanted.

If that's what it takes to get him out of office come 2020, so be it.

Saturday, March 31, 2018

Sunday Solidarity

Hong Kong has a huge population of foreign women (mostly from the Philippines and Indonesia) who work as maids or in local parlance, "Helpers."  Sundays are when they get to be a bit free:
"Once they arrive in Hong Kong, workers must be on call day and night. Many families relegate helpers to sleeping in hallways or on the kitchen floor. Shorted checks, physical abuse, and sexual assault are all too common, to say nothing of the everyday discrimination that Southeast Asians face from the territory’s Cantonese majority. With little spare income, and often poor education, most domestic workers bear these hardships in silence. The few avenues of legal recourse they have are prohibitively expensive, difficult to navigate, and can take weeks or months. If a helper is fired, she has just two weeks to find work elsewhere before she’s deported. But no one can take away their Sunday. Which is why, since the 1980s, as a critical mass of Filipino migrants took to the streets, domestic workers have made the thousands-strong outings a weekly ritual.
One pair of young friends celebrates a birthday with a lavishly decorated cake. Ladies at the next camp are doing each other’s hair. At a third, a woman snacks on a handful of melon seeds while nose-deep in a pamphlet on migrant workers’ rights.
'Sunday is when migrant workers can meet friends from their countries,' says Phosuk Gasing, an executive committee member of the IDWF who’s worked as a helper in Hong Kong for 26 years. 'They can speak the same language, taste food from their homes, and share problems and how to solve them.' The IDWF’s on-the-ground affiliate, the Federation of Asian Domestic Workers Unions, represents migrants to the government, disseminates educational materials, and advocates for survivors of human trafficking and employer abuse."
Click through for some great pictures as well.